I Heart Huckabees
I suppose I was unfairly biased for “I Heart Huckabees” going into it for two reasons. First, because Mark Wahlberg has been telling everyone he’s a Christian, and I was interested in what sort of cinematic direction that might take him and Second, because my landlords - typical suburban folk - thought it was weird and difficult to understand. We artsy-fartsies enjoy the swelling of pride we get when we can understand something the hoi-polloi finds obscure. When it was over the second time (I watched it with the commentary from the director and two principal characters) I had to conclude that there were a lot of things to like.
It helped that I have started to really believe what I already figured was true - that there’s no need to expect everyone to talk like mamby-pamby anglo church-people, because language is so cultural it’s often used as the dipstick for cultural identity. The broad spectrum of languages out there is more a symbol of our human inability to really communicate with eachother, soul to soul than a standard of moral rectitude. Language is feeble and imperfect. It works a little bit. Sometimes. (Like in the words of this here film review :) But it’s a poor measure for judging what’s really going on inside a person.
This seemingly obvious lesson is pretty important, since the movie starts out with Jason Schwartzmann’s character walking through the forest doing a mental monologue that goes something like this: “fucking asshole cocksucker fuck fuck fuck motherfucker”. Which, of itself, is a pretty harsh earful. However, he goes on to say some more stuff - how he feels like he’s not making any difference, like nothing he does matters, etc. This sets the stage for the whole movie - a film about man’s search for meaning.
Oh, that, one might say. The question. The BIG QUESTION. Been there, done that, tried it, bought the ice cream. Well, yes. But there’s a lot more here for considering, since it’s projected against the backdrop of an environmental activist group butting heads with the disturbingly-lifelike evil department store chain, Huckabees.
This brings up a lot of great points about the environment, but also about the politics of indifference and the now-almost-cliche story of corporate greed generating a willfully self-deceptive false front and soma-fizing the common folk. I won’t ruin the movie for anyone by going into all the specifics here, but I will just say that there is one scene a brilliant critique of the modern suburbanite (Christian) response to environmental issues that makes the whole movie worth not burning. Good thing we don’t have to judge a worldview by all those who espouse it.
The real meat, bones and potatoes of the thing is wrapped around the BIG QUESTION, and through a fusion (or rejection) of both nihilism/narcissism and atheistic universalism, the main character arrives at a startling conclusion. Are you ready for it? Really? Are you sure you should be taking this so lightly? Because I’m about to tell you what this movie says is the meaning of the universe, and if you hear it and think it’s a load of monkey droppings, you’ll have to start all over again. And that could really suck.
OK. Well, if you’re sure. Then here it is, the meaning of life, as taught by “I Heart Huckabees”, according to Joshua Lawrence Barkey:
— We can find a sense of meaning and peace in the midst of chaos, wrongness and existential angst by stripping away the false layers of constructed self which we have used to protect ourselves from others, and then meeting those others in an honest place with self-bankrupt love. This will allow interconnection to grow from “the manure of human troubles”. —
Hmmm.
Yup.
Well.
OK. So. What you’re saying, Mr. David O. Russell (director), is that life has meaning, but only if you let go of your Self (which is a construct that exists because you are afraid of others), accept that life is painful, and love others without fear. Nifty.
I suppose you, dear reader, expect me to tell you what I think of this idea. Allow myself to repeat.... myself. I’m here on this site to explore - not explain. What pleases me the most about this movie is that it asks important questions and looks at important issues. I’m glad it exists, because it challenges people to think about things that really matter - to look past the narrow scope of this mortal coil. As you may have guessed, getting people to think is something of a hobby of mine as well, so it’s nice to have smart, good-looking people helping out. This movie is funny, interesting, odd, vulgar, and sometimes more naughty than nice, but if you give it a fair chance, it might just get your brain working. Have a smashing day, and feel to write and tell me you think I’m an idiot. Or not.